The Social Media Hotelier
← Letters

How I sabotaged my own Instagram

The Social Media Hotelier4 min read

Ever got the feeling you had something tricky figured out… only to discover further down the line that you'd been doing it completely wrong?

That was me with Instagram.

My content marketing journey started on Facebook: I'd had decent success driving traffic, knew how to post, how to engage, all the "things".

So when I branched out onto using Instagram to market my guest house, I thought, "How different can it be?"

Turns out, very different indeed. Literally chalk & cheese.

Looking back at some of my early content now makes me properly cringe - like looking back at a wedding video and seeing myself dance like the dad I really am.

The 5 Mistakes That Taught Me Hard Lessons

1. Square/Landscape Images

Coming from Facebook, I assumed all my beautiful property photos would work perfectly on Instagram.

Big mistake.

When square or landscape images get presented on your Grid Feed, Instagram resizes them to a 3:4 ratio which can look truly awful, especially if there's text superimposed.

The solution? Always make your posts 3:4 (1080 × 1440 px) and your Reels 9:16 (1080 × 1920 px).

2. Links in Captions

To this day, links work effectively in Facebook captions, so naturally I started dropping URLs into my Instagram captions.

Then one day, whilst contributing to a weekly engagement group, I tried tapping a link in someone's caption.

Nothing happened.

So I tapped again.

Still nothing happened.

That's when it dawned on me - Instagram links in captions are completely unclickable.

So what do people have to do to see what the link leads to?

They have to write down something like "www.123xyz-throw-a-six-to-start" with pencil and paper, then faithfully type it into a browser.

Your Perfect Potential Guests have better things to do with their time (especially on the Insta).

The solution: Drive people to the link in your bio with a clear call-to-action, use link stickers in your Instagram Stories, or embrace yet another software (like ManyChat) to automatically slide into their DMs.

3. Hashtag Obsession

Back in the day, hashtags were the answer to Organic Reach and discoverability.

I'd spend ages researching the "perfect" 30 hashtags for each post. Hours and hours putting together lists of hashtags to use on different types of content.

But as Instagram's algorithms increase in complexity and power (alt-text, audio analysis, visual and text analysis, all wrapped up in an AI bow), this is no longer the case.

What I now know beyond a shadow of a doubt is that SEO and key-wording are significantly more powerful than hashtags for long-term discovery.

In fact, I wrote an entire piece about this shift from hashtags to Instagram SEO - you can read it here.

4. Engagement Groups

When increasing organic reach felt like nailing jelly to a ceiling, I joined some engagement pods - groups where we'd all like and comment on each other's posts immediately after posting.

The thinking behind these groups sounds logical: if we all support each other and engage with one another's content, we'll all get better reach.

Here's what actually happens: lots of other hosts and property managers like one another's content.

This signals to the algorithms what types of people value your content.

If a bunch of STRs like each other's content... guess what sort of accounts the algorithms will show that content to?

MORE hosts and property managers, not your Perfect Potential Guests!

There's no solution to this problem other than to stop. So if this is you - just stop, ok? You're doing your content marketing more harm than good.

5. Giveaways Designed to Grow Followers

I have never bought fake followers, but I did something almost as damaging… I ran giveaways purely to grow my follower count.

Giveaways attract people looking for freebies. Once the giveaway is over, they lose interest but often don't unfollow.

One of my now InstaBooked students originally came to me with exactly this problem.

Picture this: 21,000 followers. Sounds impressive, right? Wrong.

She had run giveaway after giveaway, each one bringing in more freebie-hunters who vanished the moment the prizes were announced.

Her engagement rate had dropped off a cliff faster than a tourist's enthusiasm for British weather.

But all the Instagram gurus keep banging on about "growth," don't they?

So she thought the solution was more followers and ran another giveaway.

This became a vicious circle - a downward spiral where each giveaway made the problem worse.

With all these followers and low engagement, the algorithms took one look at her content and thought, 'Even her own followers aren't bothered,' and promptly buried her Reach six feet under.

The result?

21,000 followers, little or no engagement, declining reach and DMs that were emptier than a library at midnight.

No enquiries. No bookings. Just digital tumbleweed.

But here's the twist: After joining InstaBooked, following the training modules and attending the regular live group sessions… she began to methodically remove the freebie-hunters (what she & I call 'finessing her audience') and her engagement started to bud like spring flowers.

Last month? Five booking enquiries landed in her DMs.

Sometimes you need fewer followers, not more.

Looking back at my own Instagram journey - from that overconfident Facebook marketer who thought he had it all figured out to someone who actually understands how the platform works - I realise these mistakes weren't just about misunderstanding Instagram.

They were about taking shortcuts instead of doing the work to truly connect with the people who matter: your Perfect Potential Guests.

The good news?

Once you understand what Instagram actually rewards (valuable content, genuine engagement, platform-specific formatting), building a presence that converts browsers into bookers becomes much more straightforward.

I made these mistakes so you don't have to.

Caught yourself making any of these mistakes?

Drop me an email at support@thesocialmediahotelier.com and I'll send you the fixes.

Takes 2 minutes, costs nothing, saves you months of frustration.

Get Letters in your inbox

Keep reading