The Social Media Hotelier
← Letters

Exposed: How Instagram Killed Hashtags (And What Property Hosts Need To Do Now)

The Social Media Hotelier5 min read

The internet had just proved something I've believed for years: the Hosts who win long-term don't chase platforms - they build systems that work regardless of algorithm changes.

While 95% of hosts are still playing the hashtag optimisation game, the future belongs to those who understand something deeper...

Let me back up a few days for you…

My wife was away this weekend.

The kids were finally asleep.

Most people would grab a beer and watch Netflix.

I grabbed my tablet and started a Google search experiment that kept me up until 2 AM.

What I discovered will either make you feel vindicated about your strategy...

Or make you want to rewrite every Instagram caption you've ever posted.

Here's what happened...

Those clients who had peppered their content with keywords? They popped right up in search results.

Those who'd ignored my advice about strategic keyword placement? Nowhere to be found.

Why was I up half the night running Google searches?

This screenshot says it all:

That's right, unless for some absurd reason you opted out… your Instagram content & profile is now searchable on Google, Bing, across the entire digital landscape.

Finally, we can kiss goodbye to hashtags and fully focus on weaving keywords into our content & profiles.

Why is this important to me as a teacher & trainer?

Because I've always railed against the generic Instagram marketing advice that quantity beats quality and that all we need to do is "just post more."

It's this type of generic suggestion from “gurus” with teams of copywriters, video-editors and graphic designers that causes small business owners to burnout with the stress of "what am I gonna post about tomorrow?"…

…or simply revert to occasional ad hoc posting because they feel they "should" (BTW: I hate that word "should")

Most Hosts fail with their Social Media marketing because they chase platforms, hacks and trends rather than building systems that transcend platforms.

This discovery validates what I've taught for years: the Hosts who win long-term don't chase algorithms, they build systems that work regardless of platform changes.

But here's what really got my attention...

The Message That Changed Everything

On Saturday, I received this text from Cheryl, an old 1-on-1 client of mine (and now good friend) who owns a jungle lodge in Belize:

Let that sink in for a moment.

A potential guest's AI assistant (ChatGPT) recommended her property directly.

This isn't some distant future scenario. This is happening right now.

Why This Changes Everything for Property Hosts

While most hosts are still focused on traditional discovery methods, a silent revolution is happening:

We're witnessing the fundamental shift from platform-dependent discovery to fully integrated digital discovery as AI tools, traditional search engines, and social media platforms continue their relentless march toward complete integration.

When someone asks ChatGPT "recommend a romantic cabin retreat in Tennessee," it's scanning the same content that Google indexes.

And guess what Google has made its name indexing? Keywords.

The same strategic keyword placement that has helped my clients appear in Instagram searches is now making them discoverable through AI recommendations.

The New Discovery Reality

Here's what hit me during my weekend testing: I watched the old way guests find properties completely flip on its head.

The old way?

Someone opens Instagram, scrolls endlessly through hundreds of posts, and maybe (if we've done our marketing jobs well) stumbles across your property.

What's happening now?

They ask Google or ChatGPT to show them "pet-friendly lakehouse rentals" and your property, your Instagram content appears as a top recommendation (providing your Profile & your Content actually says "pet-friendly lakehouse rental" in it).

Your Instagram content isn't just fighting for attention in the feed anymore.

It's becoming part of the searchable web that AI assistants scan when making recommendations.

Think about it: when Cheryl's guest needed a recommendation, they didn't scroll Instagram for hours.

They asked their AI assistant, got a curated answer, and booked direct.

That's the shift. And most hosts are missing it completely. (Especially those who haven't signed up for or don't open my emails… help 'em out & share this email with them?)

The Strategic Advantage

This shift creates three new discovery avenues for smart hosts:

1. Google Search Results: Your Instagram posts can now appear when people search for your type of property and relevant unique selling points directly on Google.

2. AI Assistant Recommendations: As Cheryl discovered, AI tools are already recommending properties based on searchable content.

3. Enhanced Instagram Discovery: The platform's own search function is becoming more sophisticated, helping ideal guests find you faster.

The Content Strategy That Opens These Doors

The difference between invisible properties and discoverable ones comes down to how you write your captions.

Instead of hashtag stuffing:

"Check out our beautiful cabin #mountains #hottub #petfriendly #familyvacation #romantic"

Try strategic keyword integration:

"Step onto our deck and just... breathe. This place sleeps eight, but honestly? It's the hot tub that'll get you. Nothing beats soaking under Tennessee stars after the kids finally crash. Works for couples too…depends what kind of weekend you're after."

This approach serves both human readers, traditional search engines and AI systems that are indexing your content for future recommendations.

FACT:

In April this year, Instagram's CEO (Adam Mosseri) went on the record yet again (this time with Brock Johnson - love him or hate him, the fact remains) to state:

"Hashtags do not significantly increase your reach on Instagram"

Watch the full interview here

Your Strategic Next Steps

1. Audit Your Recent Posts:

Look at your last 10 Instagram captions.

Do they clearly describe what you offer using the words your ideal guests would search for?

2. Test Your Discoverability:

Search for your property type + keywords that describe one or more of your unique selling points + location on Google.

Are any of your Instagram posts appearing? If not, there's opportunity waiting.

3. Optimise Your Profile:

Your Instagram Name Line (the bold text under your username) should include searchable terms like "Family Vacation Mountain Cabin + your location" instead of just your business name.

4. Track New Discovery Sources:

Like Cheryl, start asking your guests how they found you.

You might be surprised by the answers.

The Opportunity Window

Here's the beautiful part: most hosts haven't caught onto this shift yet.

While they're still debating the "best hashtag strategies," forward-thinking hosts are positioning their content to be discovered through multiple channels.

The hosts who ignore this will be left behind as the digital world continues its relentless pursuit of progress in an already highly-integrated landscape.

The sooner you adapt your content strategy, the more discovery opportunities you'll capture while your competition remains focused on outdated methods.

This isn't about chasing the latest Instagram trend. It's about positioning your property to be found wherever your ideal guests are looking… whether that's Google, ChatGPT, or Instagram's increasingly enhanced search function.

Your Moment to Act

Just this morning, I had a 1-on-1 with an InstaBooked student (you can apply for yours HERE)

My advice was exactly this:

Post less frequently, and use the time you get back to revisit your Perfect Potential Guest, your Content Pillars, and deeply consider both the messaging you're communicating and the words you are using to do so.

Quality beats quantity. Cheryl's ChatGPT direct booking proves it.

The properties that embrace this shift to keywords that speak to their Perfect Potential Guests first won't just survive platform changes… they'll thrive across multiple discovery channels across the digital landscape.

Until next time,

Paul

Get Letters in your inbox

Keep reading