You're Wasting Your Time on Instagram

This is super-important so I’m gonna get straight to the message.
Focusing your energies on Trends and Hashtags is a mistake.
When I started out on the Insta I soon realised that there was far more to it than posting pretty pictures.
So I began to research how to bend the platform to my will & experiment with different approaches.
I was soon drowning in Instagram ‘Gurus’ quick advice, ‘easy’ hacks, algorithm-pleasing tips.
Rather than lifting myself out of the swirling water of Insta-information and taking a step back…
I swam from hack-of-the-day to tip-of-the-week and back again in a never ending struggle to hold on to something, anything that would keep me afloat.
Until I ran out of steam, burned out & got out. I walked away from Instagram, frustrated, tired & cross with myself for “wasting so much time on a sh*t platform”
A few weeks later, something beyond amazing happened.
A local agency sent me a DM saying they’d seen a post of mine (how anyone saw what I’d been doing is still beyond me) and asked if I could accommodate 5 hospital cleaning staff at short notice.
They pretty much booked me out for a week.
I was flabbergasted… Instagram had provided a return on investment for my misguided efforts.
So I tentatively returned to creating content (and boy am I glad I did - Instagram now delivers 30% of my website's traffic).
This time round however, I decided to do things my way.
To this day, whenever someone tells me algorithm hacking stuff, I just basically ignore it and keep my focus on Marketing Fundamentals 101:
- Understand the Ideal Guest Persona (this will help)
- Craft a Unique Value Proposition for them
- Create a Content Strategy
- Create Engaging Content
- Measure Performance and Continually Iterate to Optimise
Quick disclaimer here. Yes, the latest trends and well-researched hashtags can improve the Reach for a specific piece of content, BUT:
Time spent trying to identify and leverage hacks is an exercise in putting lipstick on a pig.
The most common challenge we have as Hosts when leveraging Instagram into our marketing (from my experience, in our lives in general actually) is scarcity of time.
We have to become masters at prioritising our time.
When I say ‘Hacks’ I mean when we see something like "Start using these hashtags to boost your engagement, because that's what's working really well right now", or "This trending audio will 10x your Reach, but it's only going to work for the next 6 days".
The thing is if you have to jump from mini trend to mini trend to mini trend, the moment that little thing is done: you're done.
You're done because there's no substance to your content.
You're done because you’re relying on hacks.
Hashtags are the same and I can prove it.
First, let me tell you what a hashtag is:
Hashtags are an indexing system that was created in 2007. The algorithms use hashtags to understand the content of content.
Think of hashtags like the labels at the top of a stack of books in the library.
A person who always heads to a particular stack of books when they walk into a library is the equivalent of someone following a particular hashtag.
Instagram is a library and hashtags are the shelf labels.
When we use a hashtag in our content, we are telling Instagram which stack of books our content should live on… so that people who go to that stack of books can find it.
Back in the day, this was pretty much all Instagram had to go on when trying to match content with accounts that might value it (to keep them on the platform for longer and put more paid advertising in front of them – read this for a full explanation).
So deploying hashtags successfully 15, 10, or maybe even 5 years ago could be a very effective mechanism to get our content seen by accounts that were not already following us.
Since 2007, we now have SEO, Key-wording, Audio, Spoken-Word analysis, Caption analysis, video and graphics analysis, Alt-Text.
It goes on and on and on.
Then wrap this all up in AI and whilst hashtags can be powerful, the return you'll get from spending time researching them has and continues to be fast diminishing.
Here's The Proof:
In April/May of this year (2024), I ran an experiment.
I released an Instagram Reel every day for 30 days.
They were all talking head Reels, me just talking to the camera (binge them here).
None of them had any hashtags at all.
As expected, my Reach went up a little bit because Reels traditionally gain more Reach than the other content formats.
However, Reach to Non-Followers (i.e: the volume of accounts seeing my content for the very first time - Brand Awareness) was more than 3.5x the number that it was in the previous 30 days.
Plenty of key-words were in the audio that I recorded as well as in my captions, but not one hashtag was used.
My Advice:
Refocus attention and remember what the overall objective of Instagram as a platform is.
We know that Instagram wants people to click and it wants them to watch and it wants them to stay on their platform for as long as possible.
So if we just always optimise all our efforts to communicate something of value to our Ideal Guests…
Then whether something is trending or not like, “Oh, yellow sub-titles are doing really well right now.” or “Make sure you respond to every single comment within the 6 minutes. Otherwise, the algorithms will hate you forever.”…
Will make no significant difference at all.
Anytime someone tells me algorithm hacking stuff, I just basically ignore it because unless the goal of Instagram has fundamentally changed all this other stuff is just distraction.
I ignore it because the one thing that matters most is to make something that my Ideal Guests will appreciate.
I aim to create content that's so good they're going to see value in it.
And the moment they see it, they know that my Guest House is a perfect fit for their needs.
They will want to learn more.
They will want to visit my booking page to find out:
- Can they afford me?
- Do I have vacancies when they want to travel?
- Where is the Book Now button?
The algorithms are designed to spot this interest, this value exchange and leverage it for their own needs.
It doesn't matter what the algorithm-stimulating hack of the day is right now, the algorithms are going to want to distribute this content to more of my Ideal Guests.
And even if the post doesn't spread like wildfire, the 50 people who did see it are supremely likely to be my Ideal Guests and they will get the message that I want to give them.
I.e: the message that my accommodation is perfect for them. And that they are perfect for me.
The ROI in content marketing on Instagram lies in giving your Ideal Guests value: by entertaining, by informing them, by giving them something to aspire to.
If you’re not giving your Ideal Guests a reason to consume your content, it doesn't matter if you use trending audio on your Reel.
It doesn't matter how many or how few hashtags you use.
It doesn't matter whether your Instagram Reels are 6 seconds or 60 seconds long
It doesn't matter if you've added the newest trending audio.
If you’ve not understood your Ideal Guest’s desires & motivations and crafted a strategy to give them what they want: time spent trying to identify and leverage hacks is an exercise in putting lipstick on a pig.
Bottom line:
The magic lies in doing the work that you're avoiding.
The work that you're avoiding is to spend serious time understanding who your Ideal Guest is, what they want to see, building a strategy to speak to them, and then engaging them at that level.
When your content resonates with your Ideal Guest, they'll engage with it.
The algorithms will recognise this and show it to people who fit the profile of your Ideal Guest.
This small mindset shift that will revolutionise your approach to creating Content to market your Short Term Accommodation Business:
FROM
"Will this post do well with the Algorithm?"
TO
"Will this post do well with my Ideal Guest?"
FROM
"What does the Algorithm want from my content?"
TO
"What does my Ideal Guest want from my content?"
FROM
"Will the Algorithm like and promote my content?"
TO
"Will my Ideal Guest like and promote my content?"
Remember, it's the algorithms' sole purpose in life to put content in front of accounts, people who will value that content.
Instagram marketing ain't fast food, it's slow-cookin'.
So play the long game and stop looking for hacks.
Put in the work to build your foundation.
This all starts with the Guest: everything else will naturally follow.
That's it. Thank you for reading.
