You're Not Losing Followers... You're Finessing Your Audience

Let's cut to the chase. Have you ever freaked out because you saw your Instagram follower count drop? You’re not alone.
Most Short Term Accommodation business owners think they’re doing something wrong when this happens.
Most people think losing followers feels like the opposite of growth. They take it personally, thinking lots of followers is the ultimate success metric on Instagram.
Imagine the shock one of the Students in the InstaBooked Programme felt when my advice to her was to either:
- Actively cull her Followers
- OR
- Start afresh with a brand new Instagram Account
Let's call this lovely lady Michelle to save her blushes.
Michelle had enrolled in the InstaBooked Programme and then booked a Free Clarity Call. Her Instagram account had 12.4K followers.
My first thought?
"Why does Michelle need my help?"
Here’s Why:
Despite having so many followers, Michelle's last 12 posts had averaged just 35 likes and 1 comment.
That's an engagement rate of just 0.32% (way lower than what we’d expect for an account of that size).
She knew something was wrong and the algorithms knew something was wrong so they weren't giving her content the Reach it "deserved".
Michelle had focused all her efforts on growing her Follower count through giveaways instead of concentrating on giving her Ideal Guest value in everything she posted.
The result?
Thousands of followers who had zero interest in booking her accommodation but were all about free stuff.
Thousands of Followers who (at best) weren't engaging with Michelle's content or (at worst) were totally ignoring her.
The Big Idea:
Losing followers is a form of growth. It’s a sign your audience is maturing and becoming higher quality.
When people decide to unfollow your Instagram account they're unconsciously finessing your audience on your behalf.
Here’s Why:
- Quality Over Quantity: It’s better to have 125 followers who want to book a stay with you than 12,500 who couldn't care less about your content or your Short Term Accommodation Business.
- Content Matters: The content we put out is personal, but the way people respond to it isn’t always about us.
- Refined Audience: If someone unfollows you, it means they’re no longer your ideal guest. Let them go and wish them well.
My Advice to "Michelle":
Slowly Remove Inactive Followers: This would take forever and the algorithms might see it as a negative signal, thinking the account has taken a turn for the worse.
OR
Start Fresh: Create a new account, repurpose content that has performed in the past, and focus entirely on her Ideal Guest.
Never use a giveaway to grow again.
For two weeks, tell existing followers at least twice a week where they can find the new account and then switch everything over.
Realise This:
People unfollow for valid reasons that have little to do with you: They’ve already booked, they’re vacationing elsewhere, or they can no longer travel.
Bottom line: they're no longer interested in your account, so let them go.
Quality beats quantity every time when it comes to followers: "Everyone" is not your ideal guest. Your posts, ideas, emails, designs, content, branding, and offerings will be rejected by someone at some point.
The key is to take feedback seriously, but not personally.
Take Action:
Stop worrying about losing followers. Focus on engaging the right ones.
This shift in mindset will help you implement Content more effectively into the marketing strategy of your Short Term Accommodation Business.
Stay creative,
Paul
