My Secret Sauce to STR Instagram Success

Content Calendars for Rental Owners
In the digital age, creating compelling content is essential for vacation rental owners looking to attract guests and drive bookings. However, even the most outstanding content can fall flat without proper planning and strategy.
That's where a Content Calendar comes into play. Today I’ll lift the lid on what Content Calendars are, how to build one and why doing so will raise your Instagram Marketing to heights you never imagined possible.
Whether you're a seasoned host or just starting in the vacation rental business, understanding the benefits of a well-structured content calendar can make all the difference between your content soaring or suffering.
Back in 2020, when I began marketing my guest house on Instagram, my Content Creation process looked like this:
- Have a “bright” idea or take what I thought was an awesome photo.
- Write a few words to accompany the photo or hunt for a pretty picture of my house or Oxford City.
- Post it to Instagram as quickly as possible before I was “distracted” by other essential tasks for my business.
- Wonder why Instagram wasn’t showing it to many people & why those that did see my post weren’t raving about it.
- Then wait for inspiration to strike once again and repeat the process.
NOW IT'S MORE LIKE:
- I know to whom my content is addressed (Ideal Guest/Avatar)
- I only publish content that I know my Ideal Guest will appreciate
- I publish content regularly & consistently (yes, I have recently taken a break but the point remains)
- This content has already proved to resonate with my Ideal Guest
- 50% of the time my Creation Process, when active, runs on autopilot
- 32% of my website traffic comes from Instagram
Over the last 3 years I have had to learn a multitude of skills from video-editing to copywriting to sorting the generic Instagram-Guru advice from that which applies to Accommodation Businesses. Today I’m going to share with you one of the biggest factors that led to all this traffic heading to my booking page: The Content Calendar.
Whilst tactics such as using trending audio, links in Bio and compelling graphic design all have their part to play in successful Instagram Marketing… A content calendar serves as a strategic tool, ensuring that your marketing efforts are organised, consistent and above all effective.
Why Every Vacation Rental Owner Needs a Content Calendar
Organisation and Consistency:
Managing properties while also ensuring a consistent online presence can be a daunting prospect. A Content Calendar acts as a roadmap, guiding your content strategy and ensuring you're always on track.
Consistent posting not only keeps your audience engaged and strengthens your brand's authority and reliability, it also helps to continuously remind the algorithms of your presence.
Strategic Planning:
Every location has its unique events and attractions. Whether it's a local festival, a seasonal event, or a popular tourist attraction, planning your content around these can drive more engagement and bookings.
A content calendar allows you to anticipate these events and create content that resonates with potential guests. By looking at how early guests book for a particular season or event you can readily coordinate your content to align with that.
At a very basic level: posting about Christmas events at Christmas time will likely be too late to attract potential guests looking for a Christmas break. They’ll have already organised themselves and booked somewhere. Catch them at the right time with your content and you’ll be both top of mind and ready to satisfy their needs as they consider where they’ll stay.
Efficient Time Management:
Creating content on-the-fly can be stressful and often misses the mark. By dedicating specific times to brainstorm, create, and schedule content, you ensure a steady stream of quality posts ready to be shared.
Moreover, adopting the Creation process I have found most efficient (below) will not only focus the mind on a value-packed topic but also guide your creative juices for maximum output.
Performance Analysis:
A content calendar isn't just for planning; it's also for reflection. By tracking the performance of each post, you can gain insights into what's working, what's not, and where you can improve.
I frequently repeat content that has performed well. Sometimes three months later, sometimes a year later. Recycling and reframing Content is a particularly effective means of creating Content that resonates.
Here’s a perfect example of such a post. When I first published this in January 2021 (when my account was still young) it Reached 368 other accounts. At the time, that was astonishingly good for me. So in January 2022 I tweaked the caption a little and republished it… it Reached 795. This year when I published exactly the same post it Reached 1,290 Accounts.

This increase was not because of a significant growth in Follower numbers but because I was showing up consistently on the Insta and knew it would perform well because it already had done. If you know something works… why invent anything different?
How to Build Your Content Calendar
Define Your Ideal Guest:
Before you can create content that resonates, you need to know who you're speaking to. Is your property family-friendly? Or perhaps it's a romantic getaway for couples?
Understanding your target audience's preferences and interests is the foundation of any successful content strategy. If you’re unsure about who your Ideal Guest/Avatar is or think you need to revisit their definition, this will help enormously.
Determine Value Points:
What unique experiences does your property offer? Is it the breath-taking view, proximity to attractions, or perhaps the local cuisine? Identify what your Ideal Guest needs to know, what would nudge them to deciding to book with you, what sets your property apart and craft your content around these unique selling points.
Establish Content Pillars:
Think of content pillars as the main categories or themes that your content will revolve around. The Value Points will then sit under one (or more) of these Content Pillars. For a vacation rental, this could be "Local Attractions," "Guest Testimonials," or "Service & Space." These pillars ensure that your content remains varied and engaging whilst always giving your Ideal Guest value.
Set a Posting Frequency:
While it's essential to post regularly, it's equally important to ensure that the quality of your content remains high. Determine a posting frequency that's realistic for you.
The Insta-Gurus spout all types of advice about posting every day (or even multiple times per day) and usually do so themselves. The difference is: content is their business and they usually have a team of people behind them producing copy, graphics, strategy.
We are Hosts and so whilst Marketing is an important part of what we do it isn’t everything that we do. It’s far more effective to post once a week for 5 weeks than to post daily for 5 days and then not again for a month.
Consistently delivering value does not mean constantly posting content. I tried to post every day when I started researching effective Instagram Marketing.
So, to share my experience... attempting to maintain such a high rate of production whilst running a successful business led to two things:
1. My mission had become focussed on volume rather than quality. The mission had become to publish every day, rather than give my Ideal Guest value in each of my posts.
I experienced a sense of relief when I hit “publish” – no matter how badly conceived or hastily thrown together that content was. I felt gratification and a sense of accomplishment just to get something out that day.
In retrospect, I had prioritised volume over quality and was posting utter rubbish that served no purpose for anyone.
2. My Mental Wellbeing deteriorated and ultimately led to burnout. I found myself lying awake at night trying to think of ideas for content to publish the next day. “I have nothing to publish tomorrow! What shall I write about?”. This was seriously unhealthy.
Eventually I just stopped. For weeks. In fact, I very nearly abandoned Instagram for good. When I decided to try again I started with one post per week and then gradually built up the volume from there… using a homemade Content Calendar.
Content Rotation:
To keep your audience engaged, it's crucial to offer a mix of content. By rotating through your Content Pillars, you ensure that your followers receive a balanced mix of informational, promotional and value-packed content.
It's as simple as posting about Pillar 1, followed by Pillar 2, then Pillar 3, etc. This ensures that each of your valuable pillars is addressed regularly whilst maintaining the appearance of dynamic content by mixing the topics you “discuss”.
Analyse and Adapt:
The digital landscape and consumers of content are ever-evolving. What worked a few months ago might not be effective today. Regularly review your content's performance, gain insights, and tweak your content accordingly.
What to Include in Your Content Calendar:
Build out a spreadsheet with the following columns:
Day & Date
This helps align your posts with any special events or holidays as well as providing a guide to when you’re due to post.
Content Pillar & Value Point (Sub-Pillar)
For categorisation and ensuring a balanced content mix.
Hook
Your image should stop the scroll. A compelling Hook, however, is what gets viewers to actually read what you’ve written.
Caption
The place to deliver your value-bombs to your Ideal Guests.
CTA (Call-to-Action)
Directing your audience on the next steps, whether that's to book, read more, or share is essential. Any post without one doesn’t deserve engagement.
Graphic/Video
A picture is worth a thousand words. Plan your visuals to complement and enhance your written content.
Performance Metrics
Essential for tracking engagement and understanding your content's impact.

My 4-Phase Process for Content Creation:
Ideation Phase
This is where creativity flows. Think about your audience's interests, upcoming events, or any special promotions you might have.
Creation Phase
Bring your ideas to life. Craft compelling captions, source or create engaging visuals and ensure that your CTA is clear and compelling.
Evaluation Phase
Once your content is out in the world, it's time to see how it performs. Track metrics like engagement, reach, and external link clicks.
Iteration Phase
Use the insights from your evaluation to refine your strategy. Double down on what's working and re-evaluate any content that's not resonating with your audience. Try to understand why one piece of content performs well & another does not. Repeat the successes and discard the failures.
How I populate my Content Calendar
- Pick a Content Pillar to work on
- In my calendar: write as many value-packed Captions as I can in an hour
- Write as many Hooks & CTAs for each of those captions as possible in 20 minutes
- Source or create scroll-stopping images/videos that support the Caption (40 mins)
- In this two hour period, I would expect to have created 8-12 pieces of content. All I need to do now is schedule or publish them on the days my Content Calendar tells me to.
- I then move on to another Pillar, rinse & repeat.
Sometimes, if I’m feeling in a writing kind of mood I’ll move on to writing Captions for the next Pillar before moving on to Hooks & Graphics, etc.
In any event, the benefits are twofold:
- Instead of bouncing from Pillar to Pillar (from Topic to Topic) by creating your posts sequentially… you put parameters around your Ideation and stay focussed on one subject. This, in turn, leads to improved copy and pays dividends by eliminating the chance of accidental repetition.
- Rather than having to move through all of the creative tasks that go into creating posts one at a time, you can batch your creative juices into just writing captions or just putting logos onto images or just crafting hooks.
This way, you channel your creative juices and avoid the need to jump from one creative activity to another, let alone having to switch between software tools as you build your posts.
The net effect is a massive increase in your productivity, greater focus on your Ideal Guest, constant & consistent delivery of targeted value, greater engagement (leading to greater Reach).
Ultimately more potential guests will make their way to your website or booking page.
In the digital age, content is king. But even the best content can fall flat without proper planning and strategy. A content calendar is more than just an organisational tool; it's a roadmap to digital marketing success.
By planning, creating, analysing and iterating Short Term Rental Businesses can build a content strategy that not only resonates with their audience but also drives bookings and growth.
Fail to Plan and Plan to Fail
Paul ✌️
PPS: Discover how to supercharge your Instagram game in just 20 minutes. Gain valuable insights and personalised advice – no sales pitch, just pure progress.
