The Social Media Hotelier
← Letters

My Instagram Predictions for 2024

The Social Media Hotelier8 min read

As 2023 draws to a close I’ve looked ahead to what 2024 may bring and considered what I want to get from it. Unsurprisingly, this includes revisiting my strategy for marketing my Guest House on Instagram whilst analysing how Instagram has changed as a platform over the last 12 months.

What follows are the biggest Instagram changes that Hosts need to know as we head into 2024. Some of these changes and updates are predictions for 2024, some of them have been highlighted by the Instagram CEO himself and some of them are my conclusions from personal experience and recent studies into Instagram content creation & consumption.

In short? Here are my predictions about what will do well and what may no longer do well when using Instagram as a marketing platform in 2024.

The Shift Away from Reels

Instagram's focus on Reels has been a defining trend in recent years. However, as we approach 2024, this trend is experiencing a downturn. The 2021/22 influx of Reels content led to market saturation, ultimately resulting in a noticeable decline in their effectiveness. A recent study by Metricool examining over 1 million Instagram Reels revealed a drastic drop in views and they found that the average account was posting around 60% more Reels in 2023.

Stack this against demand (essentially how much attention is being given to Instagram or how much time are people spending on Instagram). We haven't seen a big increase in the time spent consuming Reels. In fact, some studies even suggest a decrease in terms of how much time people are spending on Instagram.

It follows then that if people are spending the same amount of time (or less) on Instagram and we're expecting them to consume 60% more Reels…Reels views are going to go down.

In 2021 and 2022, regularly posting Reels often led to viral success and significant follower gains. However, the current landscape has changed: going viral and converting viewers into followers has become more challenging.

This shift is due to the increased quality and quantity of Reels and the more discerning nature of the average Instagram user. I.e. unless your Reels are competing at the highest levels in a saturated “market”, they’re unlikely to gather much traction. Competition is stiff.

The 2023 Metricool study revealed a significant 76% drop in Reels views, reflecting users' experiences of declining viewership. This trend, coupled with the frustration of creating content that underperforms, indicates a shift in Instagram's algorithm. As we enter 2024, relying solely or predominantly on Reels may no longer be the most effective strategy to engender brand awareness for our Accommodation Businesses.

The Crucial Role of the Hook in Content Creation

In the world of Instagram content, the initial few seconds or the opening line - the 'hook' - is paramount. It's the make-or-break element that determines whether your audience will stay and watch/read or scroll away.

The hook, essentially the start of your content – be it the opening line of your caption, the initial moments of your video, the first slide of your carousel, or the headline of your graphic – must capture your audience's attention. It’s called a Hook and that’s exactly what it needs to do. Without a strong Hook, no one will read the value you give… let alone get as far as a Call To Action. You can learn more about crafting compelling content HERE.

I’ll be devoting more of my creative resources to perfecting this element, ensuring it effectively engages viewers from the beginning. In 2024, focusing on crafting an engaging hook will be more crucial than ever.

However… A common challenge with Instagram Content is the emphasis on posting valuable content, but even the most valuable content can fail to engage if it lacks a compelling start. Just like a book needs a strong cover, an intriguing opening chapter and a captivating title to draw readers, Instagram content needs a strong hook to retain audience interest.

The importance of a hook is evident in practices like Mr. Beast (216M YouTube Followers) spending around $10,000 on a YouTube thumbnail (the platform's equivalent of a first impression). While Instagram doesn't require such hefty investments for effective Hooks (and as Accommodation Businesses we’d never dream of dropping that sort of cash on a graphic), the principle remains the same: the initial part of your content is what truly engages viewers on Instagram.

As we move into 2024, take time to review your 2023 Content, particularly Posts/Reels that didn't perform as expected. Examine the openers to this content critically - look for elements like visual appeal, transitions and your opening words. Ask yourself if these aspects are strong enough to capture your Next Potential Guests’ attention on Instagram.

PRO TIP:

If you have a 2023 Post that didn't perform well despite your efforts, try reposting it in 2024 with a revised hook. This simple tweak could significantly enhance the performance of your content without the need to completely rebuild it.

The Resurgence of Carousels and Photos

A significant shift is occurring in the type of content that’s gaining traction on Instagram. Carousels and photos, once overshadowed by Reels, are making a comeback. This resurgence is partly due to Instagram's algorithmic adjustments which aim to balance the distribution of different content types.

Recent studies indicate a growing engagement with these formats, suggesting a valuable opportunity for Hosts to exploit.

The first indication of this impending shift came at the very start of this year, when Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri acknowledged that the platform may have overemphasised Reels. He indicated this future shift towards balancing the distribution between Reels and other content types like photos and carousels.

So: Content Creation had shifted away from images and Carousels to Reels… and Reels consumption was falling. Images and Carousels were inevitably going to improve in performance.

This shift has already shown itself in the data. The 2023 Metricool study revealed that photos and carousels are receiving more engagement and reach than in previous years, a trend expected to continue into 2024. This resurgence of traditional formats like photos and carousels offers new opportunities for Hosts creating Content.

Shares: The Ultimate Engagement Metric

As we approach 2024, the importance of shares as a metric for engagement cannot be overstated. Each share can bring in an average of 400 additional views. A Share(s) is a clear indicator that the content resonates deeply with our audiences, prompting them to spread the word and put your content in front of other accounts.

Let's consider the intention behind someone who is sharing. When someone shares your content, whether on their story, in a group chat, or via direct message, they're actively promoting it to a broader audience.

This act of sharing not only increases views but also signals the content's value to the algorithms, as the sharer believes it's worth seeing by others. Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri has emphasised this, stating that shares are the most valuable form of engagement on the platform. Shares lead to more conversations and extended time spent on Instagram.

I predict that to excel on Instagram in 2024, focussing on creating content that encourages sharing will give Hosts a significant boost in Reach. Share-worthy content typically falls into categories like thought-provoking or emotional material, controversial topics, or trending news and pop culture. These types of content are more likely to be shared, helping Hosts reach a wider audience, enhance engagement, and grow their following.

The Miniskirt Rule: Optimising Watch Rate for Reels

For Reels, my focus will shift to the watch rate: a critical metric indicating the percentage of the video watched by the audience. Short, engaging Reels with high watch rates are more likely to be favoured by Instagram's algorithm.

Instagram's updated Insights allow us to monitor and analyse the performance of Reels and will even now show you for how long a percentage of viewers actually stay tuned for. This in turn, allows you to refine your approach for optimal engagement.

Remember though, there's no one-size-fits-all length for Instagram Reels. They should be concise enough to maintain viewer attention yet sufficiently long to convey your message. I call this balance the 'Miniskirt Rule': short enough to grab and hold attention but long enough to cover the essentials. The key is to be succinct, eliminate any unnecessary pauses, and keep your content direct and to the point.

As above, Instagram's late 2023 update introduced enhanced analytics for Reels, allowing creators to track watch time, watch rate, completion percentage, and average view duration. This data is invaluable for understanding viewer engagement with your content. By analysing these metrics, you can fine-tune your Reels to optimise for watch time and viewer completion, ensuring your content resonates effectively with your audience.

Rethinking Hashtags and Trending Audios

The effectiveness of hashtags and trending audios is diminishing. While these elements are not entirely obsolete, their impact in driving engagement and growth has declined.

This decline is due to the overuse of hashtags, Instagram's enhanced SEO capabilities and a reduced reliance on hashtags for content categorisation. A few well-chosen, relevant hashtags should suffice.

Trending audios, which were highly influential in 2022, have also seen a shift in their impact. It seemed to me that Instagram became saturated with accounts that pretty much just announced new trending audios. With the benefit of 20-20 hindsight I think they were reaping the benefits of announcing a new trending audio… and the Reach of these announcements seems to have outweighed the advantages of actually using it.

This trend has led to an overemphasis on trending audios, which can lack originality and a personal touch, leading to viewer fatigue. Moreover, the focus on trending audios is often an attempt to cater more for the algorithms than to our actual audiences.

The key takeaway is to prioritise content quality over chasing trends. Use audios that resonate with you and your niche and support the message of your Content. Try hard not to succumb to the pressure of using what's trending.

Remember, new trending audios emerge daily, so it's more important to focus on creating content that genuinely serves and engages your Ideal Guests, rather than solely aiming to please the algorithms.

Final Thoughts

As Instagram continues to evolve, staying informed and adaptable is the key for Hosts looking to thriving on the platform. By understanding these trends and algorithm changes, you can strategically position your content for maximum impact. Remember, the goal is to create content that not only follows trends but also genuinely engages and resonates with your audience and Ideal Guests.

My predictions may very well miss the mark as 2024 unfolds so feel free to hold me to account if they prove to be wrong. In any event I wish you all the very best for a smooth start to 2024 and a successful year of content marketing on Instagram.

Paul ✌️


PPS: Discover how to supercharge your Instagram game in just 20 minutes. Gain valuable insights and personalised advice – no sales pitch, just pure progress.

APPLY for your Free Call today.

Get Letters in your inbox

Keep reading