Instagram's New Focus: Why Shares are the New Metric for Success

2 days ago, Adam Mosseri, Instagram’s CEO, made it abundantly clear yet again: the new currency of Instagram success is content shares. If you’re not focusing on making your posts share-worthy, you’re missing the boat.
Here’s the scoop:
Mosseri emphasised in his latest advice clip that with more users engaging through DMs rather than feed posts, Instagram is now actively boosting content that encourages sharing. It’s all about making users tap that Send icon to forward your content to friends.
Mosseri’s advice? “Don’t force it as a creator, but if you can, when you’re making content, think about making content that people would want to send to a friend, to someone that they care about, and it will help your reach over time.”
This came just a few short weeks after he responded in his weekly Ask Me Anything Stories to a question posed about how to expand your reach in the app, and the top considerations factored into the algorithm at present. Mosseri provided this answer:
“More important than watch time or like and comment counts is send rates, [and] generally, I think the rate is more important than the count. So the number of sends per reach, the number of likes per reach, the number of comments per reach. But sends per reach correlate more, in my experience, with overall reach than anything else, because we are looking to help people discover content they want to connect with friends over, and so sends is a great proxy for that sort of connection over creativity.”
It's now absolutely the case that the likelihood of people sharing our posts is now the key focus of the IG algorithms… not watch time or other forms of engagement.
As a side note, I’m underwhelmed when the CEO of a platform says, “In my experience”.... My Man, this is your show, you call the shots!
Combine Mosseri’s comments with the roll-out of displaying the Send Count for content and the writing is most definitely on the wall. This recent feature (which has been in testing for almost a year) shows how often posts are shared.
So, Sends are clearly what IG wants creators to focus on but how exactly do we create content that triggers more shares?
Harvard Business Review gives us a clue:
In a study examining social media responses to 65,000 articles, it was found that content sparking emotional responses is key to driving engagement.
This will likely come as no great surprise, though the specifics here are important.
As per the report:
“Articles with a large number of comments were found to evoke high-arousal emotions, such as anger and happiness, paired with low-dominance emotions where people felt less in control, such as fear. On the other hand, social sharing was very connected to feelings of high dominance, where the reader feels in control, such as inspiration or admiration.”
For context, a “high dominance” emotion is one that the Consumer is able to control their response to a degree, to consciously make a choice as to how they feel. A “low dominance” response is something out of their control, like fear.
So, if your aim is to trigger comments, which has long been a key driver of maximising Organic Reach, you want to use emotionally charged concepts, things that spark strong response, like anger and fear (this is sadly evident across the Social Media Landscape).
However, if it’s shares we’re after then creating inspiring, interesting and humorous content is key.
“Positive content is primed for social sharing. Our study found that admiration and happiness have a strong correlation with high dominance. This makes sense since the motivation for sharing upbeat content may be rooted in self-presentation. Passing on a positive emotional experience makes others feel good, which in turn makes the sharer look good. Including an element of surprise can help magnify the content’s positive valence.”
If you consider the type of content you might wish to share, this likely makes a lot of sense.
It also aligns perfectly with Meta’s broader strategy: they’re actively moving away from politics and negative news content in response to user feedback and political pressures.
Instead, they’re focusing on fostering positive user experiences. This is evident in their approach to Reels and the new Threads platform, both of which emphasize positive interactions.
In short, if you want comments, go for emotionally charged content that evokes strong responses like anger or fear.
If you want to drive shares, aim for content that’s inspiring, interesting, and humorous.
Here’s how I think the algorithm likely stacks up now:
- Share rates
- Watch time
- Comment rates
- Like rates
With fewer people posting and commenting, Meta is pivoting towards metrics that maximise engagement that mirror user behaviour: more DMs and more Shares.
So, how do you drive more shares of your content?
1. Create Emotionally Engaging Content:
- Highlight Unique Features: Showcase breathtaking aspects of your accommodations. Think stunning views, luxurious amenities, or unique local experiences. These are not just selling points: they create opportunities for admiration & aspiration. When you highlight what makes your property special, you can evoke emotions that compel your audience to share.
- Share Guest Stories: Authenticity wins. Share real-life testimonials and stories from your guests. These narratives resonate on a personal level and add credibility to your brand. When potential guests see positive, heartfelt stories, they are more likely to share these experiences with their network, amplifying your Reach.
- Offer Behind-the-Scenes Glimpses: Give your audience a peek behind the curtain. Show them the preparation for guests, the local attractions, and the day-to-day operations of your property. This kind of content builds a deeper connection and sparks curiosity… making it inherently more shareable.
2. Leverage Reels and Short Videos:
- In the age of instant gratification, short and snappy videos are gold. Create reels that include visually appealing subjects that engage your audience. Think of these clips as mini-tours that can captivate and entertain. These will hold viewers’ attention and make them more likely to share.
- Add Audio and Captions (for spoken word voiceovers, for example): Music and captions are your allies. Trending tunes add an emotional punch to your videos while captions ensure your message is communicated even with the sound off. This dual approach will help make your content more accessible and appealing, boosting its shareability.
3. Encourage Sharing Through Strategic Engagement:
- Ask Directly for Shares: Closed mouths don’t get fed - ask your audience to share your content. A simple call to action can go a long way. Encourage viewers to share with friends who might be interested in your properties. This direct approach can significantly increase the number of shares.
- Design Shareable Moments: Craft specific moments in your content designed to be shared. Think of awe-inspiring views, intriguing local facts, or insider tips about the best times to visit popular spots. These moments are memorable and resonate with viewers, prompting them to share.
- Engage with Users Who Share Your Content: Show appreciation for those who share your content. Engage with them, thank them, and build a sense of community. When people feel acknowledged, they are more likely to continue sharing and engaging with your content.
“This is all well & good…” I hear you say, “but it’s difficult enough to keep up with constant, continuous changes on Instagram”.
There are just 3 things we can be guaranteed in life: Death, Taxes & Change.
Social Media Platforms (Instagram included) will always be in a state of flux so whilst we might not like it... we just have to suck it up.
The trick here is not to become focussed & blinkered on the most recent shift. There is no need for a total overhaul of your Content Marketing Strategy.
What is needed is an appreciation of the reasons for the changes, acceptance that the changes are outside of our direct control and keeping them in mind when creating Marketing Content for our Ideal Guests.
Take what you’ve learned today, continue to give your Ideal Guest Value & everything will be fine…. I promise.
Stay nimble,
Paul
